That's What You Get for Trying to Kill Me

Summary

Henry homes in on a suspect in Gemma's disappearance. Malcolm goes to the police with his hunch about Charlie. Juliet becomes obsessed with Mr. Carpenter. Machado meets with an informant in Wyoming.

Guest stars

• Billy Miller as Charlie Young
• Jason Dohring as Mr. Carpenter
• Justin Bruening as Tyler Barrett
• Amber Benson as Mary Curtis
• Maximiliano Hernández as Detective Towers
• Tara Summers as Gemma Butler
• Zoey Deutch as Juliet Martin
• Darren Pettie as Jimmy Kemper
• Gage Golightly as Tessa Banner
• Emily Swallow as Elizabeth Saldana